I Beelieve In You Jelly

Pony Expresso is a bold, spreadable jam made from premium espresso.

Unlike fruit jellies, this coffee jam captures the dark, roasted soul of coffee in a rich preserve. It is sweet, savory, and packed with enough grit to get your morning moving.

The name is a tribute to the riders of the 1860 Pony Express who risked it all to deliver messages across the mountains with grit and speed.

Jam Wizard is located right off a stop of the Pony Express in Eagle Mountain, Utah.

Just like a fresh mount, this jam is designed to "get your morning moving" and deliver flavor with high velocity.

No. It has a robust roasted coffee flavor. Think of it as "edible espresso."

It is dark and daring, with a profile similar to a sweetened concentrated espresso or a coffee glaze, making it perfect for both breakfast and savory cooking.

The first time we made this jam, it was too strong so we scaled back the recipe to make sure the average coffee person in your life would enjoy the flavors.

Yes. Because it is made with real, premium espresso, it delivers a natural caffeine kick.

It is designed to be "fuel for the long ride," helping you wake up faster than a telegraph message.

Pony Expresso Coffee Jam is incredibly versatile. We find our Jam Wizard fans using it as a Coffee Steak Glaze, Burger Topping, and Charcuterie Board Accoutrements.

Check out our recommended recipes or use our AI powered Jam Wizard Recipe generating tool to create your own kitchen wizardry.

Pony Expresso Coffee Jam targets the Foodie who wants to cook with it, not just put it on toast.

For breakfast just spread on toast, bagels, or croissants for a morning jolt.

For dinner we see Jam Wizards using it as a savory glaze brushed over steak, pork chops, or burgers for a smoky, caramelized coffee crust.

It is also a dessert jam when warmed up and poured over vanilla ice cream for an instant Affogato Sundae.

When used in baking, just swirl into brownie batter for a mocha twist.

Pony Expresso Coffee Jam can take your dining guests on a caffeinated culinary adventure.

All Jam Wizard jams, jellies, and spreads are meant to be used for sensory dining experiences. This means you can create an immersive culinary event to delight your guests' five senses: taste, smell, sight, sound, and touch.

We want Jam Wizard Jams to help enhance your guests' perception of what flavors can do.

You can create memorable, emotional, and often theatrical themed meals with all of our jams, jellies, and preserves.

Absolutely. You can stir a spoonful of Pony Expresso into hot milk or plant-based milk to create an instant gourmet latte, or shake it with vodka for a quick Espresso Martini.

Pony Expresso isn't just about the caffeine; it delivers an Antioxidant Payload.

Coffee is naturally rich in antioxidants, which help your body fight off the "dust of daily stress."

It provides a mental focus boost without the jitters of synthetic energy drinks.

Yes. Our coffee jam is made with coffee, sugar, and pectin, which are naturally gluten-free ingredients.

It is the ultimate gift for the coffee addict who has everything.

Sold in a premium 11oz glass container, it offers a unique way to consume coffee that goes beyond the mug.

It’s perfect for Father’s Day, holiday stockings, or "survival kits" for tired parents.

Jam Wizard offers corporate gift baskets as well as made in Utah gift baskets.

We can design baskets to celebrate your next event or loved one in your life.

All baskets can be fully customized with your photo or logo on the jam label.

We will gladly add your customized logo on cutting boards, logo’d coffee mugs, or any other swag you want to include.

Jam Wizard can customize any jam or jelly with your photo or caption.

If you want a very unique gift to celebrate your loved one’s birthday or anniversary then reach out to us.

We can name the jam after your family member to celebrate their anniversary or create a jam for your coffee loving friend.

Allow us 3-4 business days for customization.

Restrictions do apply such as no vulgar images or words. Check out your customizations options in our store.

Jam Wizard Owner and Founder Karan Heffelfinger is a 4th generation jam & jelly alchemist whose origin story was forged in the fires of many lands.

Karan loves Eagle Mountain including volunteering at the Senior Center and Chamber of Commerce.

Karan’s tale is woven through both time and geography. Karan studied under the old world jam masters in the coal regions of Pennsylvania in the 1960s. While living there, she learned the secrets of immigrant jams and jellies developed in the old world and brought to the states.

For a time in the 1970s, she lived in the tropical realms of Panama where she learned South American culinary arts using Calafate, rhubarb, coconut, dragon fruit, and red currants. She leveled up her knowledge developing jams with rich flavors and exceptional nutritional qualities.

Most recently, she lived in the arid plains of West Texas near Fort Stockton. This land is known for their flavorful watermelon and cantaloupe jams and jellies. Her magical credentials include Texas A&M University Cooperative Extension as well as Family and Consumer Sciences at the High School level.

Her scrolls of wisdom include Associate, Bachelor and Masters degrees. Interestingly, she is a graduate of the Wilson Cake Decorating School.

Jam magic runs in her veins.